Holiday Baking Substitutions Chart: Eggs, Butter, Flour and More
A quick holiday baking substitutions chart for eggs, butter, buttermilk, brown sugar and flour, with exact amounts and the swaps to avoid.

Out of buttermilk on cookie day, or short one egg halfway through the pie crust? This holiday baking substitutions chart gives you tested swaps for eggs, butter, buttermilk, brown sugar and flour, with exact amounts from university extension tables, plus the swaps that reliably fail so you do not waste a batch.
Updated November 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Buttermilk: put 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar in a measuring cup, add milk to the 1-cup line, and let it stand 5 to 10 minutes.
- Brown sugar: 1 cup granulated sugar plus molasses works. Extension guides list ¼ cup molasses; many bakers use 1 to 2 tablespoons for a lighter result.
- Cake flour: 1 cup minus 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour. Self-rising flour: all-purpose flour plus 1½ teaspoons baking powder and ½ teaspoon salt per cup.
- Oil can replace melted butter (⅞ cup oil per cup of butter), but not butter that must be creamed or kept cold, such as in pie crust or shortbread.
- Egg swaps work best in recipes that use one or two eggs. Custards, meringues and cheesecakes need real eggs.
Quick Answer: The Holiday Baking Substitutions Chart
Bookmark this table. Amounts come from the North Dakota State University and Colorado State University extension substitution tables unless marked otherwise. Swaps change flavor and texture a little, so use them when you are stuck, not as permanent recipe changes.
| If the recipe calls for | Use instead | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 cup buttermilk | 1 tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar + milk to make 1 cup, rest 5–10 min | Biscuits, pancakes, quick breads, cakes | Slightly thinner than real buttermilk |
| 1 cup buttermilk | 1 cup plain yogurt (thin with a splash of milk if very thick) | Muffins, coffee cake, scones | Greek yogurt is thicker; thin it |
| 1 cup packed brown sugar | 1 cup granulated sugar + molasses (extension tables: ¼ cup) | Cookies, bars, crumb toppings | Less molasses gives a lighter, less chewy result |
| 1 cup packed brown sugar | 1 cup granulated sugar alone | Emergency only | Crisper, paler cookies, less caramel flavor |
| 1 cup cake flour | 1 cup minus 2 tbsp all-purpose flour | Layer cakes, cupcakes | Sift well for a finer crumb |
| 1 cup self-rising flour | 1 cup minus 2 tsp all-purpose flour + 1½ tsp baking powder + ½ tsp salt | Biscuits, quick breads | Check your baking powder is fresh |
| 1 cup all-purpose flour | 1 cup minus 1 tbsp whole wheat flour | Muffins, quick breads | Denser and nuttier; best at half and half |
| 1 cup butter | ⅞ cup vegetable oil (+ ½ tsp salt if butter was salted) | Recipes that use melted butter | Fails in creamed or laminated doughs |
| 1 cup butter | 1 cup stick margarine | Most cookies and cakes | Avoid tub spreads with high water content |
| 1 whole egg | ¼ cup commercial egg substitute | Most baking | Read the carton for baking guidance |
| 1 whole egg | 2 egg whites | Cakes, muffins | Slightly drier; add 1 tsp oil if needed |
| 1 whole egg (cookies and cakes only) | 2 tbsp water + ½ tsp baking powder | Simple drop cookies, quick cakes | Not for egg-heavy recipes |
| 1 tsp baking powder | ¼ tsp baking soda + ⅝ tsp cream of tartar | Any baking | Mix just before using |
| 1 cup sour cream | 1 cup plain yogurt | Coffee cake, dips, frostings | Tangier and a little thinner |
| 1 cup corn syrup | 1 cup sugar + ¼ cup of the recipe’s liquid | Some glazes and bars | Not for candy or pecan pie, where texture depends on the syrup |
| 1 oz unsweetened chocolate | 3 tbsp cocoa + 1 tbsp butter or margarine | Brownies, cakes | Less glossy finish |
Sources: NDSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions and Colorado State University Extension, Ingredient Substitutions. Where the two guides differ, the table notes it.
Egg Substitutes: What Works and What Fails
Eggs do several jobs at once. They bind ingredients, trap air, add moisture and fat, and set the structure as they cook. A substitute usually handles one or two of those jobs, which is why it works in some recipes and collapses in others.
Swaps that work
- Commercial egg substitute: ¼ cup per whole egg. These cartons are mostly egg whites, so they behave much like the real thing in cakes, muffins and cookies.
- Two egg whites per egg: Fine in muffins, quick breads and many cakes. You lose some richness; extension guidance allows adding 1 to 3 teaspoons of oil for each yolk you leave out.
- Water and baking powder: NDSU lists 2 tablespoons water plus ½ teaspoon baking powder per egg, for cookies and cakes only. It adds lift and moisture but no binding, so keep it to recipes with one or two eggs.
- Cornstarch for some of the eggs: Colorado State notes that 1 egg in every 3 can be replaced with 1 tablespoon cornstarch in baking. This helps when you are one egg short in a larger recipe.
Plant-based options
Ground flaxseed or chia mixed with water and left to gel, mashed banana and unsweetened applesauce are popular egg-free swaps in home baking. They are not in the extension tables cited here, so treat any ratio you find as a starting point and test a half batch first. They work best in dense, moist bakes such as brownies, muffins, banana bread and oatmeal cookies, and they add their own flavor: banana is obvious, flax is nutty.
Where egg swaps fail
- Custards, flan, pumpkin pie and cheesecake, where eggs set the filling
- Meringue, angel food cake and pavlova, which rely on whipped whites
- Choux pastry and popovers, which need eggs for steam lift
- Any recipe with three or more eggs, where the egg is the structure
For these, a trip to the store is the better choice.
Butter Substitutes
Butter matters most when it is creamed with sugar or kept cold in pieces. Creaming beats tiny air pockets into solid butter, and cold butter in pie crust and biscuits melts in the oven to create flaky layers. Oil cannot do either job.
Oil for butter
Use ⅞ cup oil for each cup of butter, with ½ teaspoon salt if the recipe expected salted butter. This works well in recipes that already call for melted butter: brownies, many quick breads, some bar cookies and boxed-mix-style cakes. Expect a slightly denser, moister crumb and less buttery flavor.
Margarine and shortening
Stick margarine can replace butter one for one in most cookies and cakes. Soft tub spreads often contain more water and can make cookies spread thin, so check the label for a product meant for baking. Shortening gives very tender, tall cookies and flaky crusts, but no butter flavor; some bakers use half butter and half shortening in pie crust for that reason.
Fruit purees for fat
Applesauce or pumpkin puree can replace part of the fat in muffins and quick breads. Start by swapping no more than half, because the result gets gummy fast. Do not use purees in shortbread, pie crust or anything meant to be crisp.
Buttermilk and Dairy Swaps
Buttermilk adds tang and acidity. The acid reacts with baking soda to make bakes rise and keeps them tender. That is why a homemade “sour milk” works: you are adding acid to regular milk.
Step-by-step homemade buttermilk
- Put 1 tablespoon lemon juice or white vinegar in a liquid measuring cup.
- Add milk until the liquid reaches the 1-cup line.
- Stir and let it stand 5 to 10 minutes. It will thicken slightly and may curdle a little; that is fine.
- Use it exactly as you would buttermilk.
Whole or 2 percent milk gives the closest result. Plain yogurt or sour cream thinned with milk also works and gives a thicker, richer batter. Plant milks such as soy can be soured the same way, though results vary by brand.
Other dairy swaps
- Whole milk: ½ cup evaporated milk plus ½ cup water.
- Half-and-half: ⅞ cup whole milk plus ½ tablespoon butter.
- Sour cream: 1 cup plain yogurt, or ¾ cup buttermilk plus ¼ cup oil.
Heavy cream is harder. Milk-and-butter mixtures can stand in for cream in a cake batter, but they will not whip. For whipped toppings, you need real heavy cream or a product designed for whipping.
Brown Sugar and Other Sweetener Swaps
Brown sugar is granulated sugar with molasses. Molasses brings moisture, a caramel note and a little acidity, which is why brown-sugar cookies are chewier and darker.
The extension tables list 1 cup granulated sugar plus ¼ cup molasses for 1 cup packed brown sugar. Many home bakers prefer 1 tablespoon of molasses per cup for a light brown sugar taste and 2 tablespoons for dark, because ¼ cup produces a very deep flavor. Both approaches are common; start lighter if you are unsure. Mix the molasses into the sugar with a fork or your fingertips until the color is even.
If you have no molasses
Plain granulated sugar works in a pinch. Cookies will spread more, bake crisper and taste less caramel-like. Adding a teaspoon of maple syrup or honey per cup of sugar can bring back a little moisture.
Honey for sugar
NDSU’s guidance: use 1 cup honey for 1 cup sugar, reduce the recipe’s liquid by ¼ cup, add ½ teaspoon baking soda per cup of honey, and lower the oven temperature by 25°F because honey browns faster. Replacing about half the sugar works better than replacing all of it in cakes, cookies and brownies.
Flour Substitutions
Cake flour
Cake flour is lower in protein, so it gives a softer crumb. To make a substitute, measure 1 cup all-purpose flour, remove 2 tablespoons, and sift. Many bakers add 2 tablespoons of cornstarch back in to soften it further; that version is a widely used kitchen method rather than part of the extension tables above.
Self-rising flour
Self-rising flour is all-purpose flour with baking powder and salt already mixed in. For each cup, NDSU lists 1 cup minus 2 teaspoons all-purpose flour plus 1½ teaspoons baking powder and ½ teaspoon salt. Whisk thoroughly so the leavening is evenly distributed.
Whole wheat and bread flour
Whole wheat flour absorbs more liquid and makes bakes heavier. Colorado State lists 1 cup minus 1 tablespoon whole wheat flour for 1 cup all-purpose in baking, but most holiday recipes taste better with no more than half whole wheat. Bread flour can replace all-purpose in yeast breads and rolls, giving a chewier result; avoid it in cakes and tender cookies.
Gluten-free flour
Measure-for-measure gluten-free blends are designed to swap one for one in cookies, muffins and cakes. Check the label for whether the blend already contains xanthan gum. Yeast breads usually need a dedicated gluten-free recipe.
Substitutions That Usually Fail
Some swaps sound reasonable but ruin the bake. Skip these during the holidays when you have no time for a second try.
| Swap | What goes wrong | Do this instead |
|---|---|---|
| Baking soda for baking powder, one for one | Metallic, soapy taste and poor rise | ¼ tsp soda + ⅝ tsp cream of tartar per tsp powder |
| Oil for cold butter in pie crust | Greasy, crumbly crust with no flakes | Use shortening or wait for butter |
| Powdered sugar for granulated in cookies | Cornstarch in it changes texture; cookies spread less and turn cakey | Use it only in recipes written for it |
| Skim milk for evaporated milk in pumpkin pie | Watery filling that may not set | Use evaporated milk or half-and-half |
| Egg replacer in custard or cheesecake | Filling stays loose | Use real eggs |
| Liquid sweetener for all the sugar in cookies | Flat, cakey, overly brown cookies | Replace half at most |
Holiday Baking Tips When Substituting
- Change one thing at a time. Two substitutions in one recipe make it hard to know what went wrong.
- Bake a test portion. For cookies, bake two or three first and adjust before baking the whole tray.
- Watch the oven. Honey, molasses and brown sugar brown faster. Check five minutes early.
- Label gifts. If you swapped in nut flour, nut milk or margarine, tell recipients, because allergies matter at shared tables.
- Do not taste raw dough. The FDA advises never eating raw flour, dough or batter, because flour is a raw ingredient and only cooking makes it safe. That applies to egg-free dough too.
If anyone eating your baking has a food allergy or a medical diet, check with their doctor or dietitian before relying on a substitution.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best substitute for buttermilk in biscuits?
Homemade sour milk: 1 tablespoon lemon juice or vinegar plus milk to make 1 cup, rested 5 to 10 minutes. Plain yogurt thinned with milk is a close second and gives a slightly richer biscuit.
Can I use white sugar instead of brown sugar in cookies?
Yes, one for one, but the cookies will be crisper, paler and less chewy. Add molasses to the white sugar if you have it to get closer to the original.
Can I replace butter with oil in cookies?
Only in recipes that call for melted butter. In recipes that cream softened butter with sugar, oil makes cookies flat and greasy. Stick margarine or shortening is a better swap there.
How do I make cake flour from all-purpose flour?
Measure 1 cup all-purpose flour, remove 2 tablespoons, and sift it well. Some bakers replace those 2 tablespoons with cornstarch for an even softer crumb.
What can I use if I run out of eggs?
For recipes with one or two eggs, try ¼ cup egg substitute, two egg whites, or 2 tablespoons water plus ½ teaspoon baking powder for cookies and cakes. For custards, cheesecakes and meringues, you need real eggs.
Can I substitute baking soda for baking powder?
Not directly. Mix ¼ teaspoon baking soda with ⅝ teaspoon cream of tartar to replace 1 teaspoon baking powder. Using soda alone gives a bitter taste and weak rise.
Keep a Copy by the Mixer
Print or screenshot the chart at the top of this page and keep it near your baking supplies through New Year’s. Most holiday emergencies are solved by sour milk, molasses-and-sugar, flour minus two tablespoons, or oil for melted butter. When a recipe depends on eggs or cold butter for its structure, accept that some bakes do not have a shortcut, and save the substitution for the next recipe.


