Concierge Wire

LLC vs S Corp Taxes: Worked Example and Form 2553 Timing

How an LLC and an S corp election are taxed differently, with a worked $100,000 example, the IRS reasonable compensation rule and when to file Form 2553.

Smith Burton · 10 min read
LLC vs S Corp Taxes: Worked Example and Form 2553 Timing

An LLC and an S corporation are not really competitors: an LLC is a legal structure set up under state law, while S corporation status is a federal tax election that an LLC (or a corporation) can choose. The real question for most owners is whether electing S corp taxation will cut their self-employment tax by more than it adds in payroll and accounting costs. This guide shows how each is taxed, works through a $100,000 profit example, explains “reasonable salary,” and covers the Form 2553 deadlines so you can decide with numbers, then confirm with a CPA.

Key Takeaways

  • A single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship by default: all net profit is subject to the 15.3% self-employment tax, up to the Social Security wage base ($184,500 for 2026) for the 12.4% portion.
  • An S corp pays you a salary (subject to payroll tax) and lets you take remaining profit as distributions that are not subject to Social Security and Medicare tax.
  • The IRS requires shareholder-employees to receive “reasonable compensation” before taking distributions; an artificially low salary invites reclassification.
  • Form 2553 must be filed within 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year the election should take effect, or any time in the year before.
  • Savings often start to outweigh extra costs somewhere around steady profits in the mid five figures and up, but your state, salary and costs decide it.

Tax rules and thresholds change, and this article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Check the official IRS sources linked below and talk to a CPA or enrolled agent before you elect.

LLC vs S Corp: What Each One Actually Is

A limited liability company is created by filing articles of organization with your state. It gives owners liability protection and flexible management. For federal tax purposes, the IRS treats a single-member LLC as a “disregarded entity” (taxed like a sole proprietorship) and a multi-member LLC as a partnership, unless the LLC elects otherwise.

An S corporation is a tax status under Subchapter S of the Internal Revenue Code. A corporation or an eligible LLC elects it by filing Form 2553. According to the IRS S corporations page, to qualify the business must be a domestic corporation (an LLC that elects is treated as one for tax purposes), have no more than 100 shareholders, have only one class of stock, and have only allowable shareholders: individuals, certain trusts and estates, not partnerships, corporations or non-resident aliens.

Feature LLC (default taxation) LLC or corporation taxed as S corp
Created by State filing State entity plus federal Form 2553
Federal income tax Pass-through to owners (Schedule C or partnership K-1) Pass-through to shareholders (Form 1120-S, K-1)
Self-employment / payroll tax 15.3% SE tax on most net profit Payroll tax on salary only; distributions exempt
Owner pay Draws, no payroll required Must run payroll for working owners
Ownership limits Any number and type of members 100 shareholders, eligible types only, one class of stock
Profit splits Flexible (per operating agreement) Strictly by ownership percentage
Paperwork Lighter Payroll filings, separate business return, more bookkeeping

How LLC Owners Pay Self-Employment Tax

If you own a single-member LLC with default taxation, your business profit lands on Schedule C, and you pay two kinds of federal tax on it: income tax at your ordinary rates and self-employment tax. The IRS states the self-employment tax rate is 15.3%: 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare.

Three details shape the bill:

  • The 92.35% factor. On Schedule SE, net earnings from self-employment are generally your net profit multiplied by 92.35%, which mirrors the employer half of payroll tax that an employee never sees.
  • The wage base. For 2026, only the first $184,500 of combined wages and self-employment earnings is subject to the 12.4% Social Security portion. The 2.9% Medicare portion has no cap.
  • Additional Medicare Tax. A further 0.9% applies above $200,000 (single), $250,000 (married filing jointly) or $125,000 (married filing separately).

You can deduct the employer-equivalent portion of SE tax when figuring adjusted gross income, which softens the income-tax side but does not reduce the SE tax itself.

How S Corp Owners Are Taxed

When your LLC is taxed as an S corp, you become a shareholder-employee. The business files Form 1120-S, and profit flows to you on a Schedule K-1, so there is still no corporate-level federal income tax in most cases. The difference is how your pay is split:

  1. Salary paid through payroll. The company withholds income tax and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare (7.65%), and pays the matching employer share (7.65%) plus federal unemployment tax.
  2. Distributions of remaining profit. These are still subject to income tax on your personal return, but not to Social Security or Medicare tax.

That second line is where the savings come from. The catch is that the IRS will not let you call everything a distribution.

Reasonable Salary: The Rule You Cannot Skip

The IRS says an S corporation must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder-employee before making non-wage distributions. Payments for the owner’s personal services are wages. The IRS lists factors that help decide what is reasonable, including:

  • Training and experience
  • Duties and responsibilities
  • Time and effort devoted to the business
  • Dividend history
  • Payments to non-shareholder employees
  • Timing and manner of paying bonuses to key people
  • What comparable businesses pay for similar services
  • Compensation agreements and the use of a formula to set pay

The IRS has won court cases reclassifying distributions as wages when owners paid themselves little or nothing. A practical approach: document what you would have to pay someone else to do your job in your area, using sources such as Bureau of Labor Statistics wage data or salary surveys, and keep that note with your records. If your business earns money mainly from employees or equipment rather than your own labor, a larger share of profit can reasonably be distributions; if you are the only one doing the work, salary should be a larger share.

Worked Example: $100,000 of Profit

Here is an illustrative example for a single-owner consulting business with $100,000 of net profit before owner pay in 2026. Assume the owner has no other wages and that $55,000 is a defensible reasonable salary for the work. The numbers cover federal Social Security and Medicare only; income tax, state taxes and the qualified business income deduction are left out to keep the comparison clean.

Scenario A: LLC with default taxation

  • Net earnings from self-employment: $100,000 x 92.35% = $92,350
  • Self-employment tax: $92,350 x 15.3% = $14,129.55

Scenario B: LLC taxed as an S corp

  • Salary: $55,000
  • Employee FICA (7.65%): $4,207.50
  • Employer FICA (7.65%): $4,207.50
  • Total Social Security and Medicare: $8,415.00
  • Remaining profit of roughly $40,800 (after salary and the employer’s share of payroll tax) passes through as distributions with no Social Security or Medicare tax.
Line LLC default S corp election
Social Security + Medicare $14,129.55 $8,415.00
Gross payroll-tax saving – about $5,715
Extra costs (estimates: payroll service, 1120-S preparation, state fees, unemployment tax) – $1,500 to $3,500 a year
Estimated net benefit – about $2,200 to $4,200

The extra-cost range is a rough planning estimate, not a quote; get real prices from a payroll provider and your tax preparer. Notice how sensitive the result is. If reasonable salary for your role were $75,000, the gross saving would fall to about $2,650, and once costs are subtracted the election might barely break even. If profit were $40,000, there may be nothing left to save after a fair salary and the added bills.

Side effects to weigh

  • Lower Social Security earnings record. Paying less into Social Security can mean smaller retirement benefits later.
  • Retirement contributions. Solo 401(k) employer contributions for S corp owners are based on W-2 salary, not total profit, so a low salary can limit them.
  • QBI deduction. The qualified business income deduction interacts with salary levels; your CPA should model both together.
  • State taxes. Some states tax S corporations at the entity level or treat them differently from LLCs. California, for example, imposes its own franchise tax on S corporations. Check your state’s revenue department.

If you want to see how owner pay changes your margins month to month, a simple profit margin calculator can help you test salary scenarios before you meet your accountant.

Form 2553 Timing and How to File

According to the Instructions for Form 2553, you can file the election:

  • no more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect, or
  • at any time during the tax year before the year it is to take effect.

The 2-month period starts on the day of the month the tax year begins. The IRS’s own example: a corporation whose first tax year begins January 7 must file between January 7 and March 21. For a calendar-year business that wants S status for all of 2027, the window runs through March 15, 2027, and you can file any time in 2026 as well.

Step by step

  1. Confirm eligibility: shareholders, one class of stock, and an EIN.
  2. Choose the effective date (usually January 1 of the coming year).
  3. Complete Form 2553, with consent signatures from every shareholder.
  4. File by mail or fax as the instructions direct for your state, and keep proof of filing.
  5. Wait for the IRS acceptance letter before assuming the election is in place.
  6. Set up payroll before your first owner paycheck, including state withholding and unemployment registrations.

An eligible LLC that files a timely Form 2553 is generally treated as having also elected to be classified as a corporation, so most LLCs do not need a separate Form 8832. Ask your preparer to confirm for your situation.

Missed the deadline?

The instructions describe late-election relief under Rev. Proc. 2013-30. In general you must have reasonable cause, act diligently once you discover the miss, file within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date, and write “FILED PURSUANT TO REV. PROC. 2013-30” at the top of page 1. If you do not qualify, you may need a private letter ruling, which carries a user fee.

When Each Structure Tends to Fit

Situation Often fits better Why
New business, profit uncertain or under about $40,000 LLC default Little or no saving after a fair salary and added costs
Steady profit well above a reasonable salary for your role S corp election Distributions above salary avoid payroll tax
Owners want unequal profit splits LLC default (partnership) S corps must allocate strictly by ownership
Foreign or corporate owners LLC default or C corp Not eligible S corp shareholders
Planning to raise venture capital Often a C corporation Investors typically want preferred stock, which S corps cannot issue

Founders preparing for outside investment also tend to plan their public story at the same time, from naming to how they will announce a launch; if that is you, our overview of announcing a startup covers the communications side.

A Checklist Before You Elect

  1. Pull last year’s and this year’s profit and a realistic forecast for next year.
  2. Research and document a reasonable salary for your role and region.
  3. Run the math with your salary, not a guess, including payroll and prep costs.
  4. Check your state’s treatment of S corporations and LLCs.
  5. Consider effects on retirement contributions, the QBI deduction and Social Security benefits.
  6. Get a CPA or enrolled agent to review before you sign Form 2553.
  7. Calendar the deadline and payroll start date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an S corp better than an LLC for taxes?

Not automatically. An S corp election can lower Social Security and Medicare tax once profits are comfortably above a reasonable salary, but it adds payroll and accounting costs. Below that point, default LLC taxation is often simpler and cheaper.

Can a single-member LLC be taxed as an S corp?

Yes. An eligible single-member LLC can elect S corporation taxation by filing Form 2553 on time. The owner then runs payroll and receives a W-2 salary plus distributions.

What is the Form 2553 deadline for 2027?

For a calendar-year business that wants the election effective January 1, 2027, file any time during 2026 or by March 15, 2027 (2 months and 15 days after the year begins).

How low can my S corp salary be?

There is no fixed percentage. The IRS requires reasonable compensation based on factors such as your duties, time spent, experience and what comparable businesses pay. Document how you set it.

Do I still pay self-employment tax with an S corp?

Not on S corp income. You pay FICA through payroll on your salary, and distributions are not subject to Social Security or Medicare tax. Income tax still applies to both.

Can I switch back from an S corp?

You can revoke an S election, but there are timing rules and generally a five-year wait before you can re-elect. Talk to a tax professional before revoking.

Run Your Own Numbers First

Start with the example above, swap in your real profit and a salary you can defend, and subtract the true cost of payroll and an extra return. If the remaining saving is meaningful and your profit is stable, an S corp election is worth a conversation with a CPA before the Form 2553 window closes. If the figure is thin, keep the simpler LLC for now and revisit next year.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *